Skip to content
Content
Command

/scooping-check

Scooping risk assessment — is someone else working on your research idea? Identifies competing groups, assesses pace of publication, evaluates whether the core insight is "in the air", and provides a watch list with search terms, key researchers, and venues to monitor.

From plugin
open-academic-paper-machine
1821 skills4 agents21 commands
Install
> /plugin marketplace add TobiasBlask/open-paper-machine
> /plugin install open-academic-paper-machine@open-paper-machine

How it fires

How this command gets triggered: by you, by Claude, or both.

  • Fires itselfClaude auto-loads it when your prompt matches the work.
  • You can call itInvoke it directly when you want it.
  • Slash command/scooping-check

Context preview

What this command does when you run it.

Scooping risk assessment — is someone else working on your research idea? Identifies competing groups, assesses pace of publication, evaluates whether the core insight is "in the air", and provides a watch list with search terms, key researchers, and venues to monitor.

Command definition

scooping-check.md
description: >
  Scooping risk assessment — is someone else working on your research idea? Identifies
  competing groups, assesses pace of publication, evaluates whether the core insight is
  "in the air", and provides a watch list with search terms, key researchers, and venues
  to monitor.
allowed_tools:
  - Agent
  - Read
  - Write
  - Glob
  - Grep
  - Bash
  - WebSearch
  - WebFetch
  - mcp__academic-search__academic_search_all
  - mcp__academic-search__academic_search_semantic_scholar
  - mcp__academic-search__academic_search_arxiv
  - mcp__academic-search__academic_search_openalex
  - mcp__academic-search__academic_snowball
user_invocable: true

/scooping-check — Is Someone Else Working on This?

Read `agents/research-strategist.md` and execute **Mode 5: Scooping Risk Assessment**.

The user provides a research idea or topic. Assess:

  • Number of capable and motivated groups working on similar problems
  • Pace of recent publication in this area (search academic databases)
  • Whether the core insight is "in the air" (multiple independent discoveries likely)
  • Time to completion for the user vs. competitors

Provide: 1. **Risk level**: Low / Medium / High scooping risk 2. **Competing groups**: Names, affiliations, recent publications 3. **Mitigation strategies**: How to differentiate, accelerate, or pivot 4. **Watch list**:

  • Search terms to monitor
  • Key researchers to track
  • Key venues where competing work would appear
  • Recommended review frequency (weekly/monthly)

Use academic search tools to ground the assessment in actual recent publications and preprints.

**$ARGUMENTS**

Read more
Ships withopen-academic-paper-machine

A Claude Code plugin that autonomously writes academic papers — from literature search to production-ready LaTeX/PDF. Scope note.

Get the whole plugin

Other commands on open-academic-paper-machine.