/map-research-landscape

name: map-research-landscape
description: "Map candidate research fields or subfields, their maturity, competition, entry barriers, and opportunity structure. Evidence/tool acquisition is host-selected."

map-research-landscape

Purpose

Map candidate research fields or subfields, maturity, competition, entry barriers, tractability, and opportunity structure.

Input contract

required: [research_intent, scope_anchor]
optional: [actor_profile, seed_evidence, constraints]
constraints: [candidate fields require evidence references and declared comparison dimensions]

Execution protocol

Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.

1. You MUST load skill `generate-candidate-directions` to generate diverse candidate fields and deliberate boundary crossings. 2. You MUST load skill `synthesize-field-panorama` to synthesize maturity, competition, entry-barrier, tractability, and opportunity evidence. If the resulting fields must be ordered, screened, or selected under explicit criteria, consider `rank-candidates` as the next tactic.

Deviation: Evidence acquisition is host-selected; do not invoke removed tool wrappers. Re-run candidate generation only when intent or scope changes materially.

Output contract

produces: [candidate_field_set, field_panorama, maturity_map, competition_map, opportunity_structure]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, open_questions]

Thresholds and quality gates

• Each candidate must have evidence for the declared dimensions or an explicit missing marker.
• The panorama must include at least one direct opportunity and one barrier per candidate.
• Acquisition sufficiency is relative to the declared eligible evidence universe; saturation is assessed by marginal information gain rather than a fixed source count.

Failure and counterexamples

Reject niche lists with no evidence, maturity claims based on publication volume alone, and opportunity claims that omit competition or entry barriers.

Provenance map

• `resolved: landscape-reconnaissance`
• `resolved: north-star-crystallization-generate-candidate-fields`
• `resolved: north-star-crystallization-landscape-synthesis`
• `resolved: broad-web-search`
• `resolved: broad-paper-search`
• `resolved: north-star-crystallization-deep-web-search`

Preserved source criteria ledger

| source | source line | kind | source criterion | |---|---:|---|---| | none retained | - | - | No source numeric/textual criterion retained after normalization. |

Context checkpoint / Delta notes

Append candidate fields, evidence references, dimension assessments, boundary-crossing rationale, and unresolved acquisition questions.