abstract-structure
Remove domain surface details to expose transferable relational/mechanistic structure at a chosen abstraction level.
@yogsoth-aiInstall SkillAutomation
Skill
/adjudicate-exchange
Evaluate competing arguments against stated criteria and produce a reasoned verdict with uncertainty.
Claude Code
$ npx -y skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange --agent claude-code
Codex
$ npx skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange -a codex -y
Cursor
$ npx skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange -a cursor -y
Gemini CLI
$ npx skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange -a gemini-cli -y
GitHub Copilot
$ npx skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange -a github-copilot -y
OpenCode
$ npx skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange -a opencode -y
Windsurf
$ npx skills add yogsoth-ai/de-anthropocentric-research-engine --skill adjudicate-exchange -a windsurf -y
SKILL.md
adjudicate-exchange.SKILL.mdname: adjudicate-exchange
description: "Evaluate competing arguments against stated criteria and produce a reasoned verdict with uncertainty."
adjudicate-exchange
Purpose
Evaluate competing arguments against stated criteria and produce a reasoned verdict with uncertainty.
Input contract
required: [arguments, critique_set, adjudication_criteria]
optional: [evidence_records, burden_of_proof, verdict_vocabulary]
constraints: [each argument and critique receives an explicit disposition]
Procedure
1. Normalize claims, warrants, evidence, and objections. 2. Map each objection to the argument component it tests. 3. Weigh support and weaknesses against the supplied criteria. 4. Emit ACCEPT, REJECT, or REVISE with conditions and uncertainty.
Output contract
produces: [verdict, argument_dispositions, conditions, uncertainty_statement]
delta_fields: [decisions, findings, uncertainties]
Quality gates
- Every argument and critique is addressed explicitly.
- Evidence is weighed without prior commitment to either side.
- Verdict vocabulary and conditions are caller-visible.
Parameterization
Caller supplies argument schema, critique schema, criteria, burden of proof, and verdict vocabulary.
Failure and counterexamples
Reject verdicts that omit objections, rely on prior commitment, or collapse uncertainty into confidence.
Provenance map
- concept: stress-test/debate-judge
- concept: convergence/judge-verdict
Read more
name: adjudicate-exchange description: "Evaluate competing arguments against stated criteria and produce a reasoned verdict with uncertainty."
adjudicate-exchange
Purpose
Evaluate competing arguments against stated criteria and produce a reasoned verdict with uncertainty.
Input contract
required: [arguments, critique_set, adjudication_criteria] optional: [evidence_records, burden_of_proof, verdict_vocabulary] constraints: [each argument and critique receives an explicit disposition]
Procedure
1. Normalize claims, warrants, evidence, and objections. 2. Map each objection to the argument component it tests. 3. Weigh support and weaknesses against the supplied criteria. 4. Emit ACCEPT, REJECT, or REVISE with conditions and uncertainty.
Output contract
produces: [verdict, argument_dispositions, conditions, uncertainty_statement] delta_fields: [decisions, findings, uncertainties]
Quality gates
- Every argument and critique is addressed explicitly.
- Evidence is weighed without prior commitment to either side.
- Verdict vocabulary and conditions are caller-visible.
Parameterization
Caller supplies argument schema, critique schema, criteria, burden of proof, and verdict vocabulary.
Failure and counterexamples
Reject verdicts that omit objections, rely on prior commitment, or collapse uncertainty into confidence.
Provenance map
- concept: stress-test/debate-judge
- concept: convergence/judge-verdict
Ships withde-anthropocentric-research-engine
A research skill graph for AI-native science. 271 markdown files. No runtime, no dependencies, no build step.
507200 skills
Stars on GitHub
Momentum
- stars in total
- 507
Other skills on de-anthropocentric-research-engine.
@yogsoth-aiInstall Skilladjust-abstraction-sco…
Move a scientific object up/down in abstraction or narrow/broaden selected scope dimensions (population, mechanism, context,…
@yogsoth-aiInstall Skilladversarial-deliberati…
Run structured attack/defense/adjudication over a claim, candidate, criterion set, or current winner. Perspective, target,…
@yogsoth-aiInstall Skillaggregate-ranking
Aggregate criterion or comparison results into an ordered recommendation under an explicit rule.
@yogsoth-aiInstall Skillanalogical-discovery
Abstract relational structure from source domains, map it to the target, validate depth, and instantiate transferable mechanisms.
@yogsoth-aiInstall Skillanalyze-constraints-re…
Characterize what blocks a research target: readiness dimensions, obstacles, bottlenecks, resource gaps, causal constraints,…
@yogsoth-aiInstall SkillMore skills from other plugins.
browser-use
Direct browser control via CDP for web interaction: automation, scraping, testing, screenshots, and site/app work. Also covers…
@browser-useInstall Skillagent-browser
Browser automation CLI for AI agents. Use when the user needs to interact with websites, including navigating pages, filling…
@vercel-labs-2Install Skill
Questions about adjudicate-exchange.
- Which coding agents can use adjudicate-exchange?
- adjudicate-exchange installs in Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, OpenCode and Windsurf with the skills CLI, using each agent's flag shown on this page. Flowy's auto-invocation, which fires a skill when your prompt matches, runs in Claude Code only.