/extract-causal-structure

name: extract-causal-structure
description: "Extract causal structure from source material at requested granularity: individual causal claims, ordered mechanism chains, mediators, assumptions, and stated boundary conditions."

extract-causal-structure

Purpose

Extract causal claims, mechanism chains, mediators, assumptions, and boundary conditions at caller-specified granularity.

Input contract

required: [source_material, extraction_granularity, causal_schema]
optional: [theory_description, domain_ontology, evidence_links]
constraints: [preserve direction and scope; distinguish observed association from asserted causation; attach evidence]

Procedure

1. Identify candidate cause, mediator, effect, conditions, and temporal order. 2. Extract X->mediator->Y chains and direct X->Y claims at the requested granularity. 3. Record assumptions, boundary conditions, and evidence for each edge. 4. Assemble the causal graph and flag unsupported or ambiguous links.

If the extracted causal relations contain incompatible directions or effects under shared scope, consider `detect-contradiction` as the next tactic.

Output contract

produces: [causal_claims, mechanism_chains, causal_graph, boundary_conditions, evidence_links]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties]

Quality gates

• Mechanism-extraction mode produces at least 1 chain per supplied theory and at least 2 chains in total where that source protocol applies.
• Every edge has direction, scope, and evidence status; association is not upgraded to causation.
• Biological strategy extraction preserves mechanism-level details of how function is achieved.

Parameterization

The caller must provide source material, theory or artifact schema, extraction granularity, causal edge vocabulary, boundary-condition fields, and evidence-link format.

Failure and counterexamples

Reject chains with missing direction, no stated mechanism, or evidence that supports only correlation while the output claims causation.

Provenance map

• resolved: hypothesis-formation/mechanism-extraction
• resolved: creative-ideation/biological-strategy-extraction
• resolved: stress-test/causal-claim-extraction
• intermediate: Pass3/extract-mechanism
• intermediate: Pass3/extract-causal-claims

Preserved source criteria ledger

| source | physical line | kind | source criterion | |---|---:|---|---| | hypothesis-formation/mechanism-extraction | 22 | numeric | Produce X->mediator->Y mechanism chains, at least 1 per theory and at least 2 total where applicable. |