/classify-simplicity-evidence

name: classify-simplicity-evidence
description: "Classify simplicity/compression as earned, weak, or decorative based on whether it forbids alternatives, compresses independent facts, or merely renames/repackages them."

classify-simplicity-evidence

Purpose

Classify explanatory compression as earned, weak, or decorative.

Input contract

required: [explanation, covered_facts, alternatives, predictions]
optional: [evidence]
constraints: [facts and alternatives must be independently listed]

Procedure

1. Check whether independent facts are compressed. 2. Check whether alternatives are forbidden and predictions constrained. 3. Classify earned, weak, or decorative and preserve rationale.

If simplicity provides discriminating support only through a vulnerable consequence, consider `test-risky-prediction` as the next tactic.

Output contract

produces: [simplicity_class, compression_evidence, missing_constraints]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions]

Quality gates

• Decorative simplicity is a relabeling with no independent compression or risky prediction.

Failure and counterexamples

Do not classify by description length or elegance alone.

Provenance map

• resolved: elegance-trap-probe