nw-ab-critique-dimensi…
Review dimensions for validating agent quality - template compliance, safety, testing, and priority validation
Domain-specific authoritative source databases, search strategies by topic category, and source freshness rules
$ npx -y skills add nWave-ai/nWave --skill nw-authoritative-sources --agent claude-codeHow it fires
How this skill gets triggered: by you, by Claude, or both.
/nw-authoritative-sourcesContext preview
The summary Claude sees to decide when to auto-load this skill.
Domain-specific authoritative source databases, search strategies by topic category, and source freshness rules
name: nw-authoritative-sources description: Domain-specific authoritative source databases, search strategies by topic category, and source freshness rules user-invocable: false disable-model-invocation: true
Supplements general reputation tiers in `source-verification` with domain-specific authorities.
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | martinfowler.com | Primary | Patterns, refactoring, enterprise architecture | | c2.com/wiki | Historical | Original wiki; pattern language origins | | microservices.io | Domain-specific | Chris Richardson's microservices patterns | | architecturenotes.co | Curated | ADRs and trade-off analysis | | infoq.com | Industry reporting | Conference talks, practitioner reports | | thoughtworks.com/radar | Trend tracking | Technology Radar adoption lifecycle |
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | docs.aws.amazon.com | Official | AWS, well-architected framework | | cloud.google.com/docs | Official | GCP services and practices | | learn.microsoft.com | Official | Azure, .NET, Microsoft ecosystem | | kubernetes.io/docs | Official | Container orchestration | | docs.docker.com | Official | Container runtime |
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | owasp.org | Standards body | Web app security, top-10 | | nist.gov | Government | NIST CSF, SP 800 series | | cve.mitre.org | Vuln database | CVE identifiers | | nvd.nist.gov | Vuln database | NVD with scoring | | csrc.nist.gov | Crypto standards | FIPS, module validation | | cisa.gov | Government advisory | Security advisories |
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | ietf.org / datatracker.ietf.org | Protocol standards | RFCs: networking, HTTP, TLS, DNS | | w3.org | Web standards | HTML, CSS, WCAG, web APIs | | iso.org | International | Quality, security, process frameworks | | ecma-international.org | Language standards | ECMAScript spec | | unicode.org | Character standards | Unicode encoding |
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | docs.python.org | Official | Python, stdlib, PEPs | | go.dev/doc | Official | Go language, stdlib | | typescriptlang.org | Official | TypeScript handbook | | rust-lang.org/learn | Official | Rust book, reference | | developer.mozilla.org (MDN) | Canonical web ref | JS, HTML, CSS, Web APIs | | docs.oracle.com/javase | Official | Java spec, API docs |
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | postgresql.org/docs | Official | PostgreSQL | | dev.mysql.com/doc | Official | MySQL | | redis.io/docs | Official | Redis | | mongodb.com/docs | Official | MongoDB | | cassandra.apache.org/doc | Official | Cassandra |
| Source | Authority | Notes | |--------|-----------|-------| | sre.google | Industry | Google SRE books | | 12factor.net | Methodology | Twelve-factor app | | dora.dev | Research | DORA metrics | | openpolicyagent.org | Policy-as-code | OPA docs |
1. Canonical authors: `{topic} site:martinfowler.com` or `site:microservices.io` 2. Conference talks: `{topic} QCon OR StrangeLoop OR GOTO conference` 3. Books/papers: `{topic} book OR paper architecture` 4. Adoption status: `{topic} site:thoughtworks.com/radar` 5. Local docs: Grep in `docs/research/` and `nWave/skills/`
1. Vuln databases: `{topic} site:cve.mitre.org` or `site:nvd.nist.gov` 2. Advisories: `{topic} site:cisa.gov` or `site:owasp.org` 3. NIST frameworks: `{topic} site:nist.gov` 4. Vendor advisories if product-specific 5. Prioritize last 6 months
1. Official docs (see database above) 2. Release notes/changelogs for version-specific info 3. Migration guides: `{framework} migration guide {version}` 4. GitHub issues/discussions for known problems 5. Stack Overflow: `{topic} site:stackoverflow.com`
1. Original author/publication 2. Case studies: `{methodology} case study OR experience report` 3. Critiques: `{methodology} criticism OR alternative OR comparison` 4. Academic: `{topic} site:arxiv.org` or Google Scholar 5. Practitioner adaptations vs original definitions
| Category | Max Age | Rationale | |----------|---------|-----------| | Security vulnerabilities | 6 months | Rapid threat evolution | | Framework versions | 1 year | API/practice changes | | Cloud service docs | 1 year | Frequent deprecation/launch | | API references | 1 year | Breaking changes common | | Architecture patterns | Evergreen | Core patterns stable | | Methodology references | Evergreen | Foundational works stable | | Language specs | Evergreen per version | Per-version permanent | | Research papers | 3 years | Check for follow-up work | | Industry trend reports | 1 year | Cite current edition only |
1. Check if newer version exists 2. Stable concept: cite with "[Published {year}; concept remains current]" 3. Time-sensitive: find current source or document age limitation in Knowledge Gaps 4. Never cite outdated security advisories as current threat intelligence
AI agents that guide you from idea to working code, with human judgment at every gate. nWave runs inside Claude Code. It breaks feature delivery into seven waves (discover, diverge, discuss, design, devops, distill, deliver).
Repo: nWave-ai/nWave
Review dimensions for validating agent quality - template compliance, safety, testing, and priority validation
Review dimensions for validating agent quality - template compliance, safety, testing, and priority validation
Review dimensions for acceptance test quality - happy path bias, GWT compliance, business language purity, coverage completeness, walking skeleton…
Detailed 5-phase workflow for creating agents - from requirements analysis through validation and iterative refinement
5-layer testing approach for agent validation including adversarial testing, security validation, and prompt injection resistance
Architectural style selection decision matrices, trade-off analysis, structural enforcement rules, and combination patterns. Load when choosing or evaluating…