/evaluate-plan

name: evaluate-plan
description: "Validate execution plan against spec. Evaluate-Loop Step 2."
model: opus
arguments:
  - name: evaluate-plan
    description: "The track ID to evaluate"
    required: true
user_invocable: true

/loop-plan-evaluator — Validate Execution Plan

Evaluate-Loop Step 2: Verify the execution plan is valid before implementation begins.

Usage

/loop-plan-evaluator <track-id>

Your Task

You ARE the loop-plan-evaluator agent. Execute the 6 validation passes:

Pass 1: Scope Alignment

Every task must trace to a spec requirement.

Pass 2: Overlap Detection

Check for duplicate work with existing tracks in `conductor/tracks.md`.

Pass 3: Dependency Check

All `depends_on` references must be valid task IDs, no circular deps.

Pass 4: Task Quality

Each task has: clear description, specific file paths, verifiable acceptance criteria.

Pass 5: DAG Validation

No cycles, unique IDs, parallel groups don't have file conflicts.

Pass 6: Board Review (Major Tracks)

If 5+ tasks or architectural changes, spawn board review:

claude --print "/orchestrator-supaconductor:board-review"

Output

Append evaluation report to `plan.md`:

## Plan Evaluation Report

| Check | Status |
|-------|--------|
| Scope Alignment | PASS |
| Overlap Detection | PASS |
| Dependencies | PASS |
| Task Quality | PASS |
| DAG Valid | PASS |
| Board Review | N/A |

### Verdict: PASS

Update `metadata.json`:

• On PASS: `current_step = "EXECUTE"`, `step_status = "NOT_STARTED"`
• On FAIL: `current_step = "PLAN"`, `step_status = "NOT_STARTED"`

Message Bus

echo "PASS" > .message-bus/events/PLAN_EVAL_COMPLETE_{track_id}.event
# or
echo "FAIL" > .message-bus/events/PLAN_EVAL_COMPLETE_{track_id}.event

Reference

Full agent instructions: `${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/agents/loop-plan-evaluator.md`