/create-adr

name: create-adr
description: Creates a NEW Architectural Decision Record (ADR) documenting a specific architectural decision. Use when the user requests "Create ADR for [topic]", "Document decision about [topic]", "Write ADR for [choice]", or when documenting technology choices, patterns, or architectural approaches. Do NOT use for reviews (use architecture-review or specialist-review), checking existing ADRs (use architecture-status), or general documentation.
allowed-tools: Read,Write,Glob,Grep,Bash(ls:*)
disable-model-invocation: true

Create Architectural Decision Record (ADR)

Creates structured ADRs following the framework's template.

Process

1. Gather Context

Ask if needed:

• What decision is being made?
• What problem does it solve?
• What alternatives were considered?
• What are the trade-offs?

2. Generate ADR Number

# Find highest ADR number
ls .architecture/decisions/adrs/ | grep -E "^ADR-[0-9]+" | sed 's/ADR-//' | sed 's/-.*//' | sort -n | tail -1

New ADR = next sequential number (e.g., if highest is 003, create 004)

3. Validate and Sanitize Input

**Security**: Sanitize user input to prevent path traversal and injection:

• Remove or replace: `..`, `/`, `\`, null bytes, control characters
• Convert to lowercase kebab-case: spaces → hyphens, remove special chars
• Limit length: max 80 characters for filename portion
• Validate result: ensure filename contains only [a-z0-9-]

4. Create Filename

Format: `ADR-XXX-kebab-case-title.md`

Examples:

• `ADR-001-use-react-for-frontend.md`
• `ADR-002-choose-postgresql-database.md`

**Valid input**: "Use React for Frontend" → `use-react-for-frontend` **Invalid blocked**: "../etc/passwd" → sanitized or rejected

5. Check Configuration

• Read `.architecture/config.yml` to check if pragmatic_mode is enabled
• If enabled and applies to ADR creation, include Pragmatic Enforcer analysis

6. Write ADR

Use the template from `.architecture/templates/adr-template.md`:

**Core sections**:

• Status, Context, Decision Drivers, Decision, Consequences
• Implementation, Alternatives Considered, Validation, References

**If pragmatic_mode is enabled**: Add Pragmatic Enforcer Analysis section:

• Necessity Assessment (0-10): Current need, future need, cost of waiting, evidence
• Complexity Assessment (0-10): Added complexity, maintenance, learning curve, dependencies
• Alternative Analysis: Review if simpler alternatives adequately considered
• Simpler Alternative Proposal: Concrete proposal for simpler approach
• Recommendation: Approve / Approve with simplifications / Defer / Recommend against
• Pragmatic Score: Necessity, Complexity, Ratio (target <1.5)
• Overall Assessment: Appropriate engineering vs over-engineering

**If deferrals enabled**: Track deferred decisions in `.architecture/deferrals.md`

7. Save ADR

Write to: `.architecture/decisions/adrs/ADR-XXX-title.md`

8. Report to User

Created ADR-XXX: [Title]

Location: .architecture/decisions/adrs/ADR-XXX-title.md
Status: [Status]

Key Points:
- Decision: [Summary]
- Main benefit: [Key benefit]
- Main trade-off: [Key trade-off]

Next Steps:
- [Immediate action 1]
- [Immediate action 2]

When to Create ADRs

**Do create for**:

• Technology choices (frameworks, databases, languages)
• Architectural patterns (microservices, event-driven, etc.)
• Infrastructure decisions (cloud provider, deployment)
• Security approaches (authentication, encryption)

**Don't create for**:

• Implementation details (function names, variable names)
• Temporary decisions
• Minor decisions with limited impact

Status Lifecycle

• **Proposed**: Documented but not approved
• **Accepted**: Approved and should be implemented
• **Deprecated**: No longer best practice
• **Superseded**: Replaced by newer ADR (reference it)

Related Skills

**Before Creating ADR**:

• "What's our architecture status?" - Check existing ADRs to avoid duplication
• "List architecture members" - See who should review the decision

**After Creating ADR**:

• "Ask [specialist] to review [the ADR]" - Get focused expert review
• "Start architecture review for [version]" - Include in comprehensive review

**Workflow Examples**: 1. Create ADR → Ask Security Specialist to review → Revise ADR 2. Architecture review → Create ADRs for key decisions → Status check

Notes

• Focus on "why" more than "what"
• Be honest about trade-offs
• Keep it concise but complete
• ADRs can be updated as new information emerges