/skeptic-review
Use when you want an adversarial steelman pass on a text artifact before it ships — surface the load-bearing claims, the strongest unaddressed counter-position, the top failure modes, and any causality-vs-correlation gaps. Encodes the Skeptic deliberator role from the
$ npx -y skills add Avyayalaya/agent-council --skill skeptic-review --agent claude-codeHow it fires
How this skill gets triggered: by you, by Claude, or both.
- Fires itselfAuto-invocation. Claude auto-loads it when your prompt matches the work.
- You can call itInvoke it directly when you want it.
- Slash command
/skeptic-review
Context preview
The summary Claude sees to decide when to auto-load this skill.
Use when you want an adversarial steelman pass on a text artifact before it ships — surface the load-bearing claims, the strongest unaddressed counter-position, the top failure modes, and any causality-vs-correlation gaps. Encodes the Skeptic deliberator role from the
Five reviewers pull your draft apart, keep their disagreement visible, and hand you one verdict — for the text you can't un-ship. A runtime-portable 5-agent council that adjudicates text artifacts before they ship.
Repo: Avyayalaya/agent-council
Other skills on agent-council.
- /adjudicator-synthesis
Use when you have run 2 or more agent-council deliberator skills on the same artifact (Skeptic, Voice & Identity, Evidence & Calibration, Strategy & Stakes) and want their structured critiques synthesized into a single SHIP / REVISE / HOLD verdict with a concrete revision brief.
Open skill - /evidence-calibration-review
Use when you want a per-claim evidence-tier audit on a text artifact before it ships — assign T1-T6 tiers to every load-bearing claim, surface calibration mismatches (high confidence on weak evidence, or honesty-theater under-claiming), and flag P11 (citation-as-decoration), P17
Open skill - /strategy-stakes-review
Use when you want a strategic-fit and opportunity-cost check on a text artifact before it ships — assess goal alignment against the operator's life-goals or portfolio framework, name the specific opportunity cost (what queued work this preempts), run the kill-criteria check, and
Open skill - /voice-identity-review
Use when you want a line-level voice and identity audit on a text artifact before it ships — surface specific voice-rule violations (banned patterns, hype words, register mismatches), apply the CXO test, and check identity coherence with the operator's voice corpus and persona
Open skill