/final-remarks

name: stage5-final-remarks
description: Fill a Stage5 final remarks template using condensed discussion markdown from all reviewers and optional rating changes. Use when generating final remarks after Stage3/Stage4 discussion.

Stage5 Final Remarks Skill

Goal

Generate a complete Stage5 final remarks markdown by filling template placeholders from multi-reviewer evidence.

Inputs

• `template_markdown`: placeholder-based template source.
• `reviewer_summaries`: array of reviewer records, each containing:
• `reviewerId`
• `condensedMarkdown`
• `originalRating` (optional)
• `finalRating` (optional)

If `template_markdown` is empty, use [references/run-template.md](references/run-template.md).

Output

Return strict JSON:

{ "filledMarkdown": "..." }

Rules

1. Preserve the template structure and section order. 2. Replace placeholders with grounded content from `reviewer_summaries` only. 3. Keep uncertain or missing items concise; do not fabricate numbers, dates, quotes, or experiments. 4. Keep tone respectful, concise, and rebuttal-ready. 5. Generate `{{key_strengths_points_markdown}}` as a concise markdown bullet list with 4-5 items summarized across reviewers. 6. Generate valid markdown table rows for `{{concern_rows_markdown}}`. 7. When rating updates are provided, reflect only explicit score transitions.