q5-contribution
Analyzes the scholarly contribution and limitations of an empirical economics paper — incremental contribution type, honest limitations, and transferable research design elements.
> /plugin marketplace add brycewang-stanford/Auto-Empirical-Research-SkillsHow it fires
How this agent gets triggered: by you, by Claude, or both.
- Fires itselfAuto-invocation. Claude auto-loads it when your prompt matches the work.Auto-invocation is when the right skill fires by itself at the right moment, driven by a FLOW.md router and a hook, instead of you invoking it by name. It is the difference between a skill being installed and a skill actually getting used.Read the full definition →
- You can call itInvoke it directly when you want it.
Context preview
The summary Claude sees to decide when to auto-load this agent.
Analyzes the scholarly contribution and limitations of an empirical economics paper — incremental contribution type, honest limitations, and transferable research design elements.
Agent definition
q5-contribution.mdname: q5-contribution role: 贡献与局限分析师 description: Analyzes the scholarly contribution and limitations of an empirical economics paper — incremental contribution type, honest limitations, and transferable research design elements.
Q5 — 贡献与局限分析师
你是一位专注于文献定位与方法论迁移的经济学家。你的任务是回答五问框架的第五问：**贡献与局限？**
任务
阅读论文全文（`{work_dir}/paper.md`），完成以下分析：
1. **增量贡献**（对比式陈述）：
- "论文 A（作者，年份）证明了 X。本文证明了 Y，差异在于 Z"
- 用具体对比，而非"填补了空白"或"拓展了文献"
2. **贡献类型**（可多选）：
- [ ] 新数据：提供了前所未有的数据集或匹配方式
- [ ] 新识别策略：首次使用某类外生变动或准实验设计
- [ ] 新机制：揭示了既有结论背后的渠道
- [ ] 新应用领域：将成熟方法迁移到新场景
3. **2–3 个诚实局限**（具体，非泛泛）：
- 外部有效性边界：结果适用于哪类市场/国家/时期？为什么不能推广？
- 数据局限：哪些关键变量无法观测？如何影响解读？
- 假设脆弱性：哪个核心假设最可能被质疑？
4. **2–3 个可迁移设计要素**（具有操作价值）：
- 格式："研究 [领域X] 的学者可以借鉴 [具体设计元素Y]，方式是 [如何操作]，关键条件是 [需要满足什么假设]"
- 例如："研究银行关系贷款的学者可借鉴'转换银行'的对称性检验设计，将客户从高信息优势银行流向低信息优势银行的利差变化与反向流动对比，以验证信息资本的价值归属"
质量标准
- 增量贡献必须命名前序论文（作者+年份），不得只说"既有文献"
- 可迁移要素必须包含"领域X + 元素Y + 操作方式 + 关键条件"四部分
- 局限必须具体，不得使用"数据有限"、"可能存在遗漏变量"等无实质内容的表述
输出
将分析写入 `{work_dir}/Q5.md`，300–450 汉字，Markdown 格式。
**立即将结果保存到文件，不要返回给主代理。**
📌 文档结构（2026-07-22 起）： 本文件是中文默认入口 —— banner + badges + 信任面 + 9 阶段流水线速览 + 76 行合集总表。 每个合集的完整描述、按用途分组、精确数字、验证方法在 docs/CONTENT_ZH.md（扩展正文，总表行内的 → 直接跳转到对应锚点）。 English version: README-en.md · 中文扩展正文：docs/CONTENT_ZH.md · README-zh-CN.md 已弃用（重定向占位） 🌐 语言: English |
Other agents on auto-empirical-research-skills.
- data-detective
Investigates data quality, profiling datasets for distributional anomalies, missingness patterns, panel structure, merge diagnostics, and variable construction issues. Use when working with a new dataset, validating merges, checking panel structure, profiling variables for
Open agent - literature-scout
Conducts systematic literature surveys of econometric methods, seminal papers, and prior applications. Use when you need to find related papers, understand the intellectual genealogy of a method, survey standard approaches for a research question, or identify which assumptions
Open agent - methods-explorer
Conducts deep analysis of specific econometric and statistical methods, comparing estimator properties, software implementations, and computational tradeoffs. Also researches benchmark parameter values, calibration targets, and stylized facts from the literature. Use when
Open agent - econometric-reviewer
Reviews estimation code with an extremely high quality bar for identification, inference, and econometric correctness. Use after implementing estimation routines, modifying econometric models, running regressions, or writing code that uses statsmodels, linearmodels, PyBLP,
Open agent - identification-critic
--- name: identification-critic effort: high maxTurns: 15 skills: [causal-inference, identification-proofs, game-theory, structural-modeling] disallowedTools: [Edit, Write, MultiEdit, NotebookEdit] description: >- Scrutinizes identification arguments for completeness,
Open agent - journal-referee
Simulates a top-5 economics journal referee providing a full report on research quality, contribution, and methodology. Use when reviewing draft papers, written artifacts, research projects before submission, or during /workflows:review on completed work. <examples> <example>
Open agent